👋 😋

This restaurant review is is part of the WOM App. Download it for Free and discover restaurants you’ll freakin’ love!

Eastside - Casa Maguey restaurant
4.7

Casa Maguey

  • Eastside
  • $$
  • Mexican
  • Casual
  • Food
    good
  • Vibe
    great
  • Perks
    good

Food: Bountiful variety, tastebuds rejoice

From the handmade tortillas to the succulent birria taco and flavorful beef fajitas, Casa Maguey’s food offerings are nothing short of exceptional. With dishes teeming with creativity, taste, and freshness, dining at Casa Maguey is a rich celebration of the senses. Portions are generous, ensuring a satisfying meal every time, and the menu is brimming with options, to cater to every palate.

  • Great Quality

    Outstanding ingredients, fresh food, made with care, time, and quality.

  • Okay Value

    Fairly priced for quality, but some find buffet pricing unclear.

Top 3 dishes at Casa Maguey

  1. 1

    Handmade Tortillas 🏆

    Fresh, handmade, and perfectly complements meats and salsas.

    Handmade Tortillas dish
  2. 2

    Birria Taco

    Birria tacos hailed as best ever, packed with flavorful and succulent meat.

    Birria Taco dish
  3. 3

    Beef Fajitas

    Meat is perfectly cooked, fajitas sizzle and are flavorful.

    Beef Fajitas dish

Vibe: Unhurried elegance, unmatched serenity

Casa Maguey's ambiance perfectly complements its food offerings with its cozy and peaceful setting. With the music and atmosphere providing a wonderful backdrop to the culinary experience, and the drink options ranging from delicious craft cocktails to an extensive wine list, one can’t help get drawn into the perfect vibe that Casa Maguey effortlessly creates.

  • Great Ambiance

    Ambiance described as perfect, cozy, peaceful with plentiful seating.

  • Okay to Entertain

    Music and atmosphere were nice; service order issues were distracting

Perks: Reassuring convenience makes dining smooth

Beyond the food, Casa Maguey continues to impress with its perks. Ample parking, smooth reservation process, and a noise level that encourages conversations add to the appeal. The restaurant’s offering of a kids' menu and play area, together with its attentive service and ability to accommodate large groups smoothly, truly delivers a holistic dining experience.

  • Great For Groups

    Accommodates large groups, provides fast service, and seating is roomy.

  • Okay For Pets

    Acknowledges dog-friendly aspect, unsure about returning for other reasons.

  • Bad Outdoor

    Customers felt patio was overcrowded and lacked enough heaters.